Wednesday, August 14, 2013

An Alternative to the American Justice System

Starting this fall, Governors State University will launch their brand new Restorative Justice Certificate program.  Dr. James “Chip” Coldren, Criminal Justice Program Coordinator, authored the certificate with the help of students within the current Criminal Justice Program.  The goal of the program is to help students become more effective leaders and problem solvers in their community, workplace, and in their home by utilizing Restorative Justice concepts and practices

Restorative justice is defined as an approach to justice that focuses on the needs of the victims and the offenders, as well as the involved community, instead of just punishing the offender. Victims take an active role in the process, while offenders are encouraged to take responsibility for their actions in order to repair the harm they've done. The offender does this by apologizing, returning stolen money, or doing community service. It is also viewed as a prevention method and an alternative for young offenders who are starting to make their way through the juvenile justice system. Dr. Coldren says it is “having people atone for the harms that they have done to people and developing competencies in people so that they don’t re-offend and commit those same harms again.”  He also says that there are natural links between some aspects of restorative justice and the corrections system.


Shaniqua Jones
Shaniqua Jones, who recently received her M.A in Criminal Justice with a focus in Restorative Justice, said that integrating restorative justice philosophies into school systems would help provide an alternative to the zero-tolerance policy. Take a conflict between two students or two parties, for example. Instead of letting them point the finger at each other, they meet individually and collectively with a facilitator and their parents to discuss who was harmed, how they were harmed, and what the consequences should be. Using this method, both of the parties involved have a voice.

In order to earn the Restorative Justice Certificate, students must take five courses: two theoretical overview classes, two practical workshops, and a fifth class that will be an evaluation course. The first two classes are called Restorative Justice and Victims and the Justice System. Restorative Justice will provide students with an overview of practices and the development of Restorative Justice, while Victims and the Justice System will inform students of the issues that victims face in the American justice system.

The two workshop courses are called Mediation and Conflict Resolution and Peacekeeping Circles. Workshop classes are typically more hands-on, so students who want to become practitioners of restorative justice will gain valuable first-hand experience. Mediation is when you have a discussion between two disputing parties with a third party acting as the mediator to help them reach an agreement. Conflict Resolution is the steps that are taken to eliminate the conflict. A peacekeeping circle is when two or more people sit in a circle to have important discussions, share stories, and resolve conflicts. It is used in many places like schools, court systems, shelters, and faith groups. Students will not only practice these skills in class, but will also be able to utilize them effectively in the field.

Peacekeeping Circle
The last course is called How to Evaluate and Assess Restorative Justice Programs. There are different approaches to evaluating a justice program; one is called an outcome evaluation. Using this method, students would determine whether or not a restorative justice program is doing what it is supposed to do and if it is having a positive impact. For example, if a restorative justice program were implemented at a high school, students would look at whether or not there been fewer conflicts between students over time.  They would then decide if that program is working, if it needs revising, or if it should just be discarded if it isn’t working.

With a certificate in restorative justice, students will become more competitive in any field they go in because it teaches specific mediation and problem-solving skills. Restorative justice isn’t just useful in the workplace; it can also make a big difference at home. “When I learned about restorative justice,” said Dr. Coldren. “I became a different parent, and I became a better parent…and I think that happens in a lot of cases.” For Dr. Coldren, involvement in restorative justice has been a life-changing experience. “I don’t know how to explain it…I’m just a really, really happy person,” he said. “Part of that has been this involvement with restorative justice. It makes me feel connected to the world.”

According to an article from The Huffington Post, restorative justice practices are “on the rise” in the U.S. and are more efficient than the current system because a) it saves time, b) it saves judicial processing money, and c) it is fair to all the parties involved (the victim, the offender and the community). Despite the reasons why many people believe that Restorative Justice is a better way to handle conflicts, there are still some who prefer the traditional ‘do the crime, do the time’ system.


Dr. James "Chip" Coldren
Dr. Coldren has a Ph.D in Sociology from the University of Chicago, but says that most of his academic and professional career has had something to do with restorative justice and the Criminal Juvenile Justice system in some way. After graduating, he spent eight years as a visiting professor and director for the Center for Research in Law and Justice at the University of Illinois Chicago (UIC). There he worked on training community members and the community police on how to work together to solve problems.  After UIC, he spent five years running a non-profit Corrections Agency as a prisoner’s advocate where he monitored the conditions of confinement in prisons, jails, and juvenile detention centers.

While doing advocacy work at the John Howard Association, there was a movement in Illinois that was partly funded by the McArthur foundation to implement reform in the juvenile justice system. His involvement helped introduce him to restorative justice, but his very first exposure was a monograph written by Carolyn Nichol on how restorative justice fits with community policing and restorative justice practices that were implemented in Great Britain. “That kind of opened my eyes to what restorative justice was and how it also fits so neatly with community policing.” He said.

During his last year at the advocacy group, GSU was having an external assessment done of its criminal justice program by a nationally known leading expert in restorative justice. He said that the program needed to be modernized and strongly recommended adding restorative justice. At the time, GSU needed a new program coordinator and brought in Dr. Coldren after he was encouraged to apply by a colleague. Once he was hired, he was told by his dean to integrate restorative justice, so for the next ten years he did just that and the response from students has been strong. “As I was doing that,” he said. “I started to think about the community and the culture here at Governors State…and maybe we should be thinking [as a community] of ways to integrate restorative justice and…conflict resolution on campus.” This is where student leaders like Shaniqua Jones and Nikki Holloway came in. If fact, Jones, who is on the student senate, is currently working with the new dean of students to integrate restorative justice into the student conduct code.

If restorative justice sounds interesting to you, then I encourage you to consider earning a certificate in it. Be sure to come back next week for the next article in the New Programs series.

Until next time Tweaders…TWAG ON!

For more information, contact:

Dr. James “Chip” Coldren: jcoldren@govst.edu 

Shaniqua Jones: shananderson1@gmail.com

1 comment: